PwC - Evidence Match
A tool within the 0-to-1 NGA platform for auditors to reduce time spent on a key workflow by simplifying and matching findings and supporting documentation from clients using AI and data integrations.
Client:
PwC
Industry:
AI, Financial
Team:
Sam Baker (Product) & Pablo Ferrari (Engineer)
Deliverables:
Product Design, UX & Product Strategy
Context:
2024-Present


Foundation
Having lead design on the end-to-end design for Disrupt AI, the MVP platform that laid foundation for the NGA platform, Evidence match presented it's own challenges being a key step in the overall end-to-end journey. Though the overarching obstacles that users faced remained the same, Evidence match brought about its own set of challenges.
Problem Statement
Evidence matching is a highly manual, time consuming process fragmented across multiple disconnected platforms, forcing auditors to repetitively locate, match, and review documentation without standardized criteria or workflows - resulting in wasted effort, inconsistent quality, and costly rework.
Solution
Addressed the core user needs and pain points through an AI automated tool. Some key features we defined include automated sample to evidence matching, evidence dashboard for big picture insights, side by side view of evidence and extracted details, and much more.
Foundation
Having lead design on the end-to-end design for Disrupt AI, the MVP platform that laid foundation for the NGA platform, Evidence match presented it's own challenges being a key step in the overall end-to-end journey. Though the overarching obstacles that users faced remained the same, Evidence match brought about its own set of challenges.
Problem Statement
Evidence matching is a highly manual, time consuming process fragmented across multiple disconnected platforms, forcing auditors to repetitively locate, match, and review documentation without standardized criteria or workflows - resulting in wasted effort, inconsistent quality, and costly rework.
Solution
Addressed the core user needs and pain points through an AI automated tool. Some key features we defined include automated sample to evidence matching, evidence dashboard for big picture insights, side by side view of evidence and extracted details, and much more.
Foundation
Having lead design on the end-to-end design for Disrupt AI, the MVP platform that laid foundation for the NGA platform, Evidence match presented it's own challenges being a key step in the overall end-to-end journey. Though the overarching obstacles that users faced remained the same, Evidence match brought about its own set of challenges.
Problem Statement
Evidence matching is a highly manual, time consuming process fragmented across multiple disconnected platforms, forcing auditors to repetitively locate, match, and review documentation without standardized criteria or workflows - resulting in wasted effort, inconsistent quality, and costly rework.
Solution
Addressed the core user needs and pain points through an AI automated tool. Some key features we defined include automated sample to evidence matching, evidence dashboard for big picture insights, side by side view of evidence and extracted details, and much more.

Ideation
With Evidence match having its own set of challenges, it was important to dive deeper into the current process, and the pain points that users face.
Competitive analysis: Competitor Evidence Match workflows, even with AI, still utilize Excel. Although Excel remains the primary tool that users are familiar, I wanted to push the boundary creating an centralized and automated experience with improved progress tracking and reduced rework loops.
Journey Map & Personas: With many of the PMs being former auditors, I conducted informal user interviews or conversations in which I gathered key pain points.
Pain points included:
Tooling limitations and Disconnect system
Unclear status, handoffs, and rework loops
Manual, time consuming evidence matching


User Flow: Based on the pain points identified, I created a user flow that details the Evidence match experience as one integrated system. From user actions and decisions to moments where AI and data integrations take place, this user flow informed the design flow as well as how it seamlessly fits into the end-to-end platform.

Ideation
With Evidence match having its own set of challenges, it was important to dive deeper into the current process, and the pain points that users face.
Competitive analysis: Competitor Evidence Match workflows, even with AI, still utilize Excel. Although Excel remains the primary tool that users are familiar, I wanted to push the boundary creating an centralized and automated experience with improved progress tracking and reduced rework loops.
Journey Map & Personas: With many of the PMs being former auditors, I conducted informal user interviews or conversations in which I gathered key pain points.
Pain points included:
Tooling limitations and Disconnect system
Unclear status, handoffs, and rework loops
Manual, time consuming evidence matching


User Flow: Based on the pain points identified, I created a user flow that details the Evidence match experience as one integrated system. From user actions and decisions to moments where AI and data integrations take place, this user flow informed the design flow as well as how it seamlessly fits into the end-to-end platform.

Ideation
With Evidence match having its own set of challenges, it was important to dive deeper into the current process, and the pain points that users face.
Competitive analysis: Competitor Evidence Match workflows, even with AI, still utilize Excel. Although Excel remains the primary tool that users are familiar, I wanted to push the boundary creating an centralized and automated experience with improved progress tracking and reduced rework loops.
Journey Map & Personas: With many of the PMs being former auditors, I conducted informal user interviews or conversations in which I gathered key pain points.
Pain points included:
Tooling limitations and Disconnect system
Unclear status, handoffs, and rework loops
Manual, time consuming evidence matching


User Flow: Based on the pain points identified, I created a user flow that details the Evidence match experience as one integrated system. From user actions and decisions to moments where AI and data integrations take place, this user flow informed the design flow as well as how it seamlessly fits into the end-to-end platform.

Iteration
While Evidence Match is a complex and data-rich experience, I focused on addressing these main pain points maintaining an organized layout and clear hierarchy.
Evidence Match went through several iterations but at its core the design of this new integrated and connected system emphasizes clear statuses and dashboard views for easy tracking of samples, it demonstrates AI automated matching of documentation and samples, and provides seamless handoffs and insights for both preparer and reviewer personas.

Throughout the process, I conducted multiple rounds of user testing validating my designs and ensuring the needs of our users and the business. Users struggled with:
Expectation gaps: Users form wrong understanding of how system should work
Missing capabilities: Users are blocked because of functionality is missing or doesn't exist. Users expressed concerns about the scalability for specific scenarios.
Clarity: Users see the Ui but donβt initially understand
Based on user feedback, I scaled the design to support multiple document and sample matching as well as created increased clarity through clearer messaging, notifications, iconography, and use of concise tooltips and labels. Overall, Evidence match received positive feedback with majority of users indicating that this tool significantly saves time and effort.
Iteration
While Evidence Match is a complex and data-rich experience, I focused on addressing these main pain points maintaining an organized layout and clear hierarchy.
Evidence Match went through several iterations but at its core the design of this new integrated and connected system emphasizes clear statuses and dashboard views for easy tracking of samples, it demonstrates AI automated matching of documentation and samples, and provides seamless handoffs and insights for both preparer and reviewer personas.

Throughout the process, I conducted multiple rounds of user testing validating my designs and ensuring the needs of our users and the business. Users struggled with:
Expectation gaps: Users form wrong understanding of how system should work
Missing capabilities: Users are blocked because of functionality is missing or doesn't exist. Users expressed concerns about the scalability for specific scenarios.
Clarity: Users see the Ui but donβt initially understand
Based on user feedback, I scaled the design to support multiple document and sample matching as well as created increased clarity through clearer messaging, notifications, iconography, and use of concise tooltips and labels. Overall, Evidence match received positive feedback with majority of users indicating that this tool significantly saves time and effort.
Iteration
While Evidence Match is a complex and data-rich experience, I focused on addressing these main pain points maintaining an organized layout and clear hierarchy.
Evidence Match went through several iterations but at its core the design of this new integrated and connected system emphasizes clear statuses and dashboard views for easy tracking of samples, it demonstrates AI automated matching of documentation and samples, and provides seamless handoffs and insights for both preparer and reviewer personas.

Throughout the process, I conducted multiple rounds of user testing validating my designs and ensuring the needs of our users and the business. Users struggled with:
Expectation gaps: Users form wrong understanding of how system should work
Missing capabilities: Users are blocked because of functionality is missing or doesn't exist. Users expressed concerns about the scalability for specific scenarios.
Clarity: Users see the Ui but donβt initially understand
Based on user feedback, I scaled the design to support multiple document and sample matching as well as created increased clarity through clearer messaging, notifications, iconography, and use of concise tooltips and labels. Overall, Evidence match received positive feedback with majority of users indicating that this tool significantly saves time and effort.

Outcome
The Evidence Match tool effectively addressed the challenges faced by new and experienced auditors, validating its potential for increased adoption.
Impact
Estimated +15% in time saved by the business. Based on testing, teams actually averaged around +45% in time saved.
Won 2 Gold awards from the Brandon Hall Group Excellance in Technology Awards for delivering measurable results through programs, strategies, and technologies β especially in innovation, AI, and the future of work.
Won award from the International Innovation Award (IIA) for the second consecutive year, winning the Service & Solution category.
As the overall platform has evolved, Evidence Match has gone through several iterations and improvements by other talented designers. In the meantime, I've continue to oversee and delegate enhancements to Evidence Match while taking lead on new experiences in the platform.
Time saved by the business
+15%
Time saved by engagement teams
+45%
Global recognition awards won
3
Outcome
The Evidence Match tool effectively addressed the challenges faced by new and experienced auditors, validating its potential for increased adoption.
Impact
Estimated +15% in time saved by the business. Based on testing, teams actually averaged around +45% in time saved.
Won 2 Gold awards from the Brandon Hall Group Excellance in Technology Awards for delivering measurable results through programs, strategies, and technologies β especially in innovation, AI, and the future of work.
Won award from the International Innovation Award (IIA) for the second consecutive year, winning the Service & Solution category.
As the overall platform has evolved, Evidence Match has gone through several iterations and improvements by other talented designers. In the meantime, I've continue to oversee and delegate enhancements to Evidence Match while taking lead on new experiences in the platform.
Time saved by the business
+15%
Time saved by engagement teams
+45%
Global recognition awards won
3
Outcome
The Evidence Match tool effectively addressed the challenges faced by new and experienced auditors, validating its potential for increased adoption.
Impact
Estimated +15% in time saved by the business. Based on testing, teams actually averaged around +45% in time saved.
Won 2 Gold awards from the Brandon Hall Group Excellance in Technology Awards for delivering measurable results through programs, strategies, and technologies β especially in innovation, AI, and the future of work.
Won award from the International Innovation Award (IIA) for the second consecutive year, winning the Service & Solution category.
As the overall platform has evolved, Evidence Match has gone through several iterations and improvements by other talented designers. In the meantime, I've continue to oversee and delegate enhancements to Evidence Match while taking lead on new experiences in the platform.
Time saved by the business
+15%
Time saved by engagement teams
+45%
Global recognition awards won
3
Other Cases
Other Cases




